@ talisman,
Hier nog een interessante pagina van 2007 over de Talpiot tombe door Ben Witherington III (*).
En lees vooral het 'New Adddendum' waar Eusebius geciteerd wordt in verband met het graf van James, broer van Jezus. Dit zal u meteen duidelijk maken dat het hier een tweede rede betreft waarom de beenderen van James nooit in de Talpiot tombe gelegen hebben.
Ook interessant is de analyse over de meest populaire namen gevonden op gebeenten.
Voor de rest lijken de aantijgingen hier reeds weergegeven stand te houden.
Ik citeer :
First of all, I have worked with Simcha. He was the producer of the Discovery Channel special on the James ossuary which I was involved with. He is a good film maker, and he knows a good sensational story when he sees one. This is such a story. Unfortunately it is a story full of holes, conjectures, and problems. It will make good TV and involves a bad critical reading of history. Basically this is old news with a new interpretation. We have known about this tomb since it was discovered in 1980.
Voeg er nog het volgende citaat bij :
Professor Amos Kloner from bar Ilan University has already told the German press “It's a beautiful story but without any proof whatsoever." He is important since he did extensive work and research on this very tomb and its ossuaries and came to negative conclusions published in a journal in 1996. In short, this is old news, to which has been added only the recent DNA testing and statistical analysis neither of which makes the case the film makers want to make.
(*) Ben Witherington III is professor of New Testament at Asbury Theological Seminary. He has a Ph.D. from the University of Durham, England, and has taught at Ashland Theological Seminary, High Point College, Duke Divinity School and Gordon-Conwell Theological Seminary. He has written more than 30 books.
Als jij je geroepen voelt en ook je volgelingen
om de analyze van deze experten te negeren, tja, wat wil je dan nog ? Case sluiten zeker 
Hier nog een interessante pagina van 2007 over de Talpiot tombe door Ben Witherington III (*).
En lees vooral het 'New Adddendum' waar Eusebius geciteerd wordt in verband met het graf van James, broer van Jezus. Dit zal u meteen duidelijk maken dat het hier een tweede rede betreft waarom de beenderen van James nooit in de Talpiot tombe gelegen hebben.
Ook interessant is de analyse over de meest populaire namen gevonden op gebeenten.
Voor de rest lijken de aantijgingen hier reeds weergegeven stand te houden.
Ik citeer :
First of all, I have worked with Simcha. He was the producer of the Discovery Channel special on the James ossuary which I was involved with. He is a good film maker, and he knows a good sensational story when he sees one. This is such a story. Unfortunately it is a story full of holes, conjectures, and problems. It will make good TV and involves a bad critical reading of history. Basically this is old news with a new interpretation. We have known about this tomb since it was discovered in 1980.
Voeg er nog het volgende citaat bij :
Professor Amos Kloner from bar Ilan University has already told the German press “It's a beautiful story but without any proof whatsoever." He is important since he did extensive work and research on this very tomb and its ossuaries and came to negative conclusions published in a journal in 1996. In short, this is old news, to which has been added only the recent DNA testing and statistical analysis neither of which makes the case the film makers want to make.
(*) Ben Witherington III is professor of New Testament at Asbury Theological Seminary. He has a Ph.D. from the University of Durham, England, and has taught at Ashland Theological Seminary, High Point College, Duke Divinity School and Gordon-Conwell Theological Seminary. He has written more than 30 books.
Als jij je geroepen voelt en ook je volgelingen