Finkelstein's boek ' The Bible Unearthed', de eerste uitgave, wordt meerdere keren tegen gesproken door zijn collega's. Zo wordt hij verweten geen rekening te houden met de recentste studies van honderden nieuwe gepubliceerde teksten en brieven van het Midden Brons tijdperk Mari. Hij getuigt van bijbelse onkunde en negeert de extra buiten bijbelse gegevens.
Integendeel van wat Finkelstein zegt wordt Shechem herhaaldelijk genoemd in Genesis 33-37. Verder waren de namen van de aartsvaders niet 'algemeen' in latere periodes.
Finkelstein heeft het verkeerd over Edom als hij zegt, ik citeer :
"as a "fully developed state" only in the late eighth century B.C. This is contradicted by the excavations directed by Thomas Levy in the lowland mining settlements of the Wadi Feinan and the evidence there for monumental building and major copper production phases as early as the twelfth century B.C. and again in the tenth and ninth centuries. See Thomas E. Levy et al., (....)
Again, the view that Genesis 14 "provides geographical information relevant only to the seventh century B.C.E." is not true. In fact, the only time when Elam challenges the West Semitic world is in the eighteenth century B.C. Mari texts (cf. Heimpel, Letters to the King of Mari, p. 609, for some of the references). Thus the texts of Genesis 14:1 and 5 that place a king of Elam at the head of a coalition of forces that move into the western Levant could not have been imagined in the seventh century B.C., but appear authentic to the geopolitics of the eighteenth century B.C. It is not necessary to go on as this review of pp. 45-52 of Finkelstein's contribution demonstrates the weaknesses inherent in his presentation. This is not merely a question of taking the alternative side of an argument; it is a matter of not recognizing the existence of facts (especially) in texts that directly contradict statements. "
Bron (door mij benadrukt)
Letters to the King of Mari.
Review article in Denver Journal : The Bible Unearthed. (The authors always present their interpretation of the archaeological data but do not mention or interact with contemporary alternative approaches. Thus the book is ideologically driven and controlled. )
Het wordt Finkelstein meerdere keren verweten dat hij geen rekening houdt met de gevonden opschriften of teksten van de Oudheid, dat hij arrogant is en collega's die het met hem niet eens zijn onheus behandeld. !
Integendeel van wat Finkelstein zegt wordt Shechem herhaaldelijk genoemd in Genesis 33-37. Verder waren de namen van de aartsvaders niet 'algemeen' in latere periodes.
Finkelstein heeft het verkeerd over Edom als hij zegt, ik citeer :
"as a "fully developed state" only in the late eighth century B.C. This is contradicted by the excavations directed by Thomas Levy in the lowland mining settlements of the Wadi Feinan and the evidence there for monumental building and major copper production phases as early as the twelfth century B.C. and again in the tenth and ninth centuries. See Thomas E. Levy et al., (....)
Again, the view that Genesis 14 "provides geographical information relevant only to the seventh century B.C.E." is not true. In fact, the only time when Elam challenges the West Semitic world is in the eighteenth century B.C. Mari texts (cf. Heimpel, Letters to the King of Mari, p. 609, for some of the references). Thus the texts of Genesis 14:1 and 5 that place a king of Elam at the head of a coalition of forces that move into the western Levant could not have been imagined in the seventh century B.C., but appear authentic to the geopolitics of the eighteenth century B.C. It is not necessary to go on as this review of pp. 45-52 of Finkelstein's contribution demonstrates the weaknesses inherent in his presentation. This is not merely a question of taking the alternative side of an argument; it is a matter of not recognizing the existence of facts (especially) in texts that directly contradict statements. "
Bron (door mij benadrukt)
Letters to the King of Mari.
Review article in Denver Journal : The Bible Unearthed. (The authors always present their interpretation of the archaeological data but do not mention or interact with contemporary alternative approaches. Thus the book is ideologically driven and controlled. )
Het wordt Finkelstein meerdere keren verweten dat hij geen rekening houdt met de gevonden opschriften of teksten van de Oudheid, dat hij arrogant is en collega's die het met hem niet eens zijn onheus behandeld. !